Back to Writing Personal Experiments

Let me tell you what this post is NOT.

It is not a "5am changed my life and now I am a productivity god" post. There are plenty of those. They're mostly aspirational marketing.

This is what actually happened when I committed to a consistent morning practice — same time, same basic structure, 90 days in a row — and tracked the results honestly.

Some of it surprised me. Some of it was disappointing. All of it was useful.

📋

The experiment.

The rules were simple:

Alarm at 5am. No phone for the first 60 minutes. 20 minutes of silence / prayer / sitting (whatever showed up). 20 minutes of reading (Scripture, Stoics, or Desert Fathers — rotating). 20 minutes of journaling or planning. Then whatever came next — gym, walk, coffee, work.

I kept a daily log. Not long — just a sentence or two. What was present. What was hard. What surprised me.

Here's what 90 days of that looks like from the inside.

📆

The honest log (highlights).

WEEK 1 — Days 1–7

The alarm is offensive. The silence feels fake. I kept checking my phone by day 3. Reset on day 4. The first 20 minutes of "silence" was mostly just noticing how loud my thoughts are. Not peaceful. Just loud.

WEEK 3 — Days 15–21

Something shifted around day 16. The alarm still stings but there's less resistance once I'm up. The silence started feeling less like nothing and more like something. Can't explain it. Just true.

WEEK 6 — Days 36–42

The reading section became the anchor. I was surprised — I expected the silence to be the most valuable. It wasn't. Sitting with a page of Marcus Aurelius or Abba Poemen at 5:15am hits differently than at 8pm. There's no performance. Just me and the text.

WEEK 9 — Days 57–63

Missed three days in a row due to travel. Noticed the difference immediately. Not productivity — that was fine. Something harder to name. Less grounded. More reactive. More noise in my head. Restarted on day 61.

WEEK 13 — Days 87–90

I don't want to stop. That's the most honest thing I can say. Not because it feels great every morning. Because I know now what the alternative costs.

✅

The results — honest version.

✓ What Worked

  • Significantly less reactivity during the day
  • Better quality of thought in the first two hours of work
  • Deeper Scripture engagement — context matters, distraction doesn't
  • More intentional start to conversations — less snap reactions
  • A sense of groundedness that lasted well past the practice itself

✕ What Didn't Work

  • Productivity didn't measurably increase — that wasn't the point, but I expected it
  • Sleep suffered until I committed to being in bed by 10pm
  • The silence section was often just wrestling — rarely "peaceful"
  • Journaling lost energy around week 7 — switched to bullet notes instead
  • The 90-day streak pressure was counterproductive — missing days felt like failure

"The morning practice didn't make me more productive. It made me more present. Those aren't the same thing — and one of them is worth more."

🎯

What I'd do differently.

Drop the streak thinking. The value isn't in the count — it's in the cumulative orientation. Missing a day doesn't undo the formation. Treating a miss like a moral failure does.

The 20/20/20 structure worked well for me. But I'd loosen it. Some mornings the silence runs long because something is happening there. Let it. The structure serves the practice — the practice doesn't serve the structure.

And I'd start with 15 minutes, not 60. The hardest part isn't the discipline. It's the first three weeks when it feels like absolutely nothing is happening.

Something is happening. It's just happening below the surface, where you can't measure it yet.

Give it 21 days before you decide.

Dave Barry
Dave Barry

Retired superintendent. EdD. Ordained pastor. Spiritual Director. Student of how humans grow — in the weight room, on the Harley, at the shelter, and in the quiet minutes nobody else sees.