← Back to all posts

There is an odd little week in the American calendar. On Thursday we sit around a table and thank God for what we have. On Friday, some of us get up before dawn to stand in line for what we do not have. The turkey is barely cold before the advertising starts telling us that what we were grateful for yesterday is not quite enough.

I am not writing to scold anybody about Black Friday. I have bought a discounted tool or two in my life, and I once stood in a parking lot at 5 a.m. for a television that I am fairly sure is now in a landfill. I am writing because I have learned that the space between Thursday and Friday is one of the best places I know to practice a single, unfashionable word: enough.

The Ancient Word for It

The writer of Hebrews put it plainly: “Let your conversation be without covetousness; and be content with such things as ye have” (Hebrews 13:5). Paul told Timothy that “godliness with contentment is great gain” (1 Timothy 6:6). Notice that he did not say godliness with more stuff, or godliness with a better deal. Contentment was the gain.

“Nothing is enough for the man to whom enough is too little.” — Epicurus

The Greek philosopher Epicurus, who gets unfairly remembered as a party animal, actually lived on bread, water, and the occasional pot of cheese. He saw that desire has no natural ceiling. If you do not decide where enough is, the market will decide for you, and the market’s answer is always “a little more.”

What the Research Says About Buying Happiness

Modern psychology has spent fifty years confirming what Epicurus and Paul already knew. In a famous 1978 study, Philip Brickman and his colleagues found that lottery winners were not much happier than people who had not won, once some time had passed. The name for this is hedonic adaptation. We get used to new things quickly. The new truck, the bigger screen, the kitchen remodel all deliver a lift, and then the lift fades and becomes the new normal.

Tim Kasser’s research on materialism adds a harder edge. Across many studies, people who place a high value on money, image, and possessions tend to report lower well-being and more anxiety. Wanting more is not neutral. It costs something.

But here is the hopeful part. In 2008, Elizabeth Dunn, Lara Aknin, and Michael Norton published a study in Science showing that people who spent money on others reported greater happiness than those who spent the same amount on themselves. Even small amounts made a difference. Money spent on relationships and generosity seems to resist adaptation in a way that money spent on stuff does not.

“Spending money on others promotes happiness.” — Dunn, Aknin & Norton, Science (2008)

What I Had to Learn the Hard Way

Early in our marriage, my wife and I had a December we still talk about. We had four kids, a teacher’s salary, and a strong desire for our children to have the Christmas we saw on television. We did not plan. We just bought. Each purchase made sense by itself. Together they made a credit card bill that followed us into April.

What I remember about that Christmas is not the gifts. I cannot tell you one thing we bought. What I remember is the knot in my stomach every time the mail came in January. The joy lasted a morning. The stress lasted a season.

The next year we did something different. Before Thanksgiving we sat at the kitchen table with a pad of paper and decided, in advance, what the whole season would cost: gifts, travel, food, giving, all of it. We wrote every name down. We put a number next to each one. We decided where the money was coming from before we spent a dime. And we put generosity on the list first, not last.

I would love to tell you we never went over again. We did, a few times. But the plan changed the conversation. When the ads came, we were not asking “is this a good deal?” We were asking “is this in the plan?” That is a much easier question to answer at 5 a.m. in a parking lot.

A Plan Before the Pressure

This week I added that kitchen-table exercise to the site as a tool called The Holiday Spending Plan. It takes about thirty minutes. You list everyone you plan to give to, set a total for the season before you shop, include giving and hospitality, and decide what you will do when you feel the pull of a deal that is not on the list.

The reason it works is simple. Behavioral economists call it a precommitment. You make the decision while your head is clear, so you do not have to make it while the countdown clock is ticking on a website. Odysseus tied himself to the mast before he sailed past the Sirens. He did not trust his willpower in the moment, and neither should we.

Practicing Enough This Week

Here is what I am asking you to try before Friday. Sit down with your spouse, a trusted friend, or just a pen and paper. Write your holiday plan. Put a number on the whole season. Put at least one line on it that is for someone who cannot pay you back. Then, on Thursday, when you give thanks, give thanks specifically for three things you already own that you once wanted badly.

You might find, as I did, that gratitude on Thursday is the best defense against covetousness on Friday. Contentment is not the absence of desire. It is desire that has learned where to stop.

Where would your season look different if you decided what enough was before the stores did?

← More Writing