← Back to all posts

For most of my career I kept a to-do list. I was good at it. I had legal pads, then planners, then an app on my phone that buzzed at me. As a principal I could tell you on any Monday morning the twenty-three things that had to happen before Friday. What I could not tell you was which of those twenty-three things I should never have agreed to in the first place.

That is the problem with a to-do list. It only grows. Every meeting, every email, every “Dave, could you just…” adds a line. Nothing ever comes off except by completion or by quiet, guilty neglect. Over thirty years in education I watched good leaders, myself included, slowly suffocate under the weight of things they were still doing only because they had done them last year.

The tool that changed this for me is almost embarrassingly simple. It is a second list, the one most of us never write: the Stop-Doing List.

Why This Tool Exists

Jim Collins made the idea famous. In his research on companies that went from good to great, he noticed that the leaders who made the leap were as disciplined about what they stopped doing as about what they started. He has written about keeping a personal stop-doing list for years, and he once said it was more important than his to-do list. When I first read that, I laughed. Then I looked at my calendar and stopped laughing.

The ancients knew this long before Collins. Marcus Aurelius, who was running an empire while writing in his journal at night, told himself that most of what we say and do is not essential, and that if we cut it out we will have more time and more tranquility. He was not advising laziness. He was advising subtraction in service of what matters.

“If you seek tranquility, do less. Or more accurately, do what is essential.” — Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 4.24

Scripture puts it in the rhythm of seasons. “To every thing there is a season, and a time to every purpose under the heaven” (Ecclesiastes 3:1). A time to plant and a time to pluck up what was planted. Most of us are very good at planting. Very few of us ever schedule the plucking up. And Jesus himself, with crowds pressing in and needs everywhere, “withdrew himself into the wilderness, and prayed” (Luke 5:16). He left things undone on purpose.

Why It Works: Your Brain Prefers Adding

Here is the part that convinced me this was not just a nice idea. In 2021, a team of researchers led by Gabrielle Adams and including Leidy Klotz published a set of studies in Nature showing that people systematically overlook subtraction when they try to improve something. Asked to fix a design, a recipe, an itinerary, or an essay, people overwhelmingly add things, even when taking something away would work better. And they are even more likely to add when they are busy or distracted.

Read that last line again. The more overloaded you are, the less likely your brain is to even consider stopping something. That is exactly backward from what you need, and it explains why the most exhausted leaders I coach are usually the ones adding yet another initiative.

“People systematically overlook subtractive changes.” — Adams, Converse, Hales & Klotz, Nature (2021)

Peter Drucker called the cure “systematic abandonment.” He urged organizations to ask regularly of every activity: if we were not already doing this, would we start it now? If the answer is no, the next question is how quickly we can stop. A Stop-Doing List is just Drucker’s question, asked out loud, on paper, by one person.

Who It Is For

This tool is for the leader who keeps saying “once things settle down.” It is for the pastor whose week is full of meetings that started as a good idea in 2014. It is for the retired person who somehow has less free time than when they worked. It is for anyone whose calendar no longer reflects what they say they value. If you have ever read my post about what my calendar says about what I actually value, this is the tool that lets you do something about it.

How to Use It

The full steps are on the Tools page, but here is the shape of it. Set aside twenty minutes. Pull up your calendar for the last four weeks and write down every recurring commitment: meetings, reports, committees, habits, even the evening scrolling. Next to each one, ask Drucker’s question: If I were not already doing this, would I start it today?

Mark each line Keep, Change, or Stop. Then pick no more than three items to stop. Not ten. Three. For each, write the date you will stop and the one person you need to tell. Then actually tell them.

The first time I did this as a principal, one of the items was a weekly staff bulletin I had written every Friday for years. It took me two hours. When I finally asked the staff, most admitted they skimmed it at best. I replaced it with a five-minute stand-up on Monday mornings, and I got two hours of my Friday back. Nobody missed the bulletin. I was the only one holding on.

When to Use It

I do this four times a year, at the turn of each season, and any time I catch myself saying “I don’t have time” about something I claim matters: prayer, my wife, my grandchildren, the gym. Late November is a perfect time. The holidays are about to pile on extra commitments, and the new year will tempt you to add a dozen resolutions. Before you add anything, subtract something.

One warning from experience. Some things on your list will feel impossible to stop because of guilt, not value. That is worth noticing. Sometimes the thing we cannot let go of is the thing that tells us we are needed. The Desert Fathers would call that a passion to be examined, not obeyed.

Your Turn

This week, before Thanksgiving, take twenty minutes and write a list with a heading you have probably never written before: Things I Will Stop Doing. Put three items on it. Tell one person. Then notice what grows in the space you made.

What is one thing you are still doing only because you did it last year?

← More Writing