For a good stretch of years, I dreaded Thanksgiving dinner. I want to be honest about that, because I am a pastor and I am supposed to love the holidays. I did love the turkey, the grandchildren, and the football. What I dreaded was the forty-five minutes after the pie, when someone would bring up politics or church or money, and the table would split into teams.
I was not an innocent bystander. I had opinions, and I had spent thirty years in classrooms and pulpits being the person who explains things. Put a little sugar and a lot of family history in me, and I could turn a disagreement about a news story into a lecture. One year my youngest son pushed back from the table and said quietly, “Dad, I came home to see you, not to be taught.” He went out to the porch. I sat there with my pie and my point, and I knew I had won the argument and lost the evening.
That was the year I started preparing for Thanksgiving the way I used to prepare for a hard meeting.
“If it be possible, as much as lieth in you, live peaceably with all men.” — Romans 12:18
Peace Is a Plan, Not a Mood
I love how honest Paul is in that verse. If it be possible. He knows it sometimes is not. As much as lieth in you. He knows you only control your half. But he does not let us off the hook for our half, and I had been neglecting mine. I showed up to family gatherings tired, hungry, and ready to be right, and then I was surprised when things went badly.
Proverbs says, “A soft answer turneth away wrath: but grievous words stir up anger.” John Gottman, who has studied couples in his research lab for decades, found something that sounds like a footnote to that proverb. In his studies, the way a conflict conversation began, in its first three minutes, predicted with remarkable accuracy how it would end. He called a hostile opening a “harsh startup.” Conversations that start harsh tend to end harsh. I suspect the same is true of holiday dinners. The tone is often set before anyone sits down.
Three Things I Do Now
I arrive tended to. I eat a real lunch. I take a nap if I can. I run what I call the HALT Check in the car: am I hungry, angry, lonely, or tired? A man who is running on empty will find a fight in a gravy boat. If I am carrying some old resentment toward someone who will be there, I pray about it on the drive, by name. It does not always dissolve, but it loosens.
I bring questions instead of positions. I decided years ago that my job at the table is to be the most curious person there, not the most correct. I bring two or three real questions: What was the best part of your year? What are you learning right now? What is something you are worried about? People who feel interesting rarely feel attacked. My grandchildren will tell me things over a question they would never tell me over a lecture.
“Attention is the rarest and purest form of generosity.” — Simone Weil
I keep a pass phrase ready. When a topic starts to heat up, I have a sentence I have practiced: “I can tell we see that differently. I would rather hear about your kids right now.” It is not avoidance. Some conversations deserve a quieter day, a smaller group, and two cups of coffee. Thanksgiving is not the place to settle a disagreement that the whole country cannot settle. It is a place to remind each other that we belong to one another anyway.
The Walk That Changed Our Afternoon
A few years ago my wife started something that has become a family tradition. After dinner, before the pie, she stands up and announces a walk. Anyone who wants to come, comes. Usually it is half the family, a couple of dogs, and at least one grandchild on someone’s shoulders. We walk for fifteen or twenty minutes.
Something happens on that walk that does not happen at the table. People walk side by side instead of face to face, which makes hard things easier to say. The kids run ahead. My son and I have had more honest conversations on that walk than we did in years of sitting across from each other. And there is good research behind the timing, too. A short walk after a big meal helps the body handle the rush of sugar that follows it. I wrote it up as a simple tool, The After-Meal Walk, on the Tools page.
When It Still Goes Sideways
Some of you are carrying something heavier than a political disagreement into this holiday. An estranged child. A sibling who still says cruel things. A parent whose dementia makes every visit a grief. I do not want to pretend that a few good questions will fix that. Sometimes the most faithful thing you can do is shorten the visit, step outside to breathe, or decide not to go this year and send a kind note instead. Paul said if it be possible for a reason.
But in my experience most of our holiday conflict is smaller than that. It is tired people, hungry people, and people who love each other and have forgotten how to show it. That kind of conflict yields to preparation, curiosity, and a walk.
Last year my son was the one who stood up and called the walk. On the way back he put his hand on my shoulder and said, “This is my favorite part now.” Mine too, son.
Your Practical Takeaway
Before Thanksgiving, sit down for ten minutes and write three things: the name of one person at the table you want to bless, two questions you will ask, and the sentence you will use to step out of a heated topic. Then plan one walk. Which person at your table needs your curiosity more than your opinion this year?